-
It may work for you two. I have some concerns about how this could be abused. I used your trade as an example because that is what we are working with today, but there is potential this becomes commonplace and it's very difficult to manage and enforce from my seat. And I'm still not certain you both agree on the definition of prospect to be named later.
-
usually there is a day or so notice from what I see. So I can use that to an advantage I think too. Just trytin to put imo
-
So are we pretty much saying this trade is a no go? Im glad this happened, so we could figure this out. I think it definately requires a trust factor between myself and Sco... My thoughts were that it would be a player not currenlty playing in the MLB. For example, Urias would still be an option. Also, if I see Sco trade a player that I had my eyes on, my fault not his... Its really not that complicated. Also, from having so many prospects, I get noitfied when he they are being called up
-
So prospects on your roster as of today are not eligible? Does he have to tell you immediately after you win the auction? What if you pick up a prospect, trade him, then shizzo decides that's the prospect he wants in the ptbnl deal, because you said any prospect you pick up. Or what if you pick up a 'prospect' tomorrow and he makes a roster in 2017 and is a star. Could shizzo wait for the breakout and then demand him? It all seems ambiguous.
-
After additional thought, until we have clearly defined rules regarding ptbnl I am opposed to it
-
Easy, hosmer and ozuna for McCullers and a throw in is not a strong offer. lol love the thought though
-
It happens all the time in real sports. I just thought it was a fun idea. I don't care if its vetoed. Selfishly I expect several nice offers to come. Right away... From everyone who thought it was sooo bad....
-
how you can trade an asset you don't have?
-
I don't see an issue with it not being someone on a current roster. Shizzo and I laid it out for any prospect that I pick up between now and the final day of the 2017 season.
-
i suppose not. its a deal involving a player that wasnt on my team at the time, but i suppose it only becomes ptbnl if i had traded for travis before winning waino. just wanted to be fully transparent with what we are talking about here.
-
that's not really a ptbnl deal, is it? had you lost the waino auction, there would not have been a trade.
-
full disclosure, shizzo and i did a ptbnl deal earlier. our deal was devon travis for a very specific ptbnl, adam wainwright. we committed to it, i won the waino auction and then we processed the deal. Is that sequence a problem? Because Waino wasnt on my roster Or is it fine because the trade wasnt made until waino was on my roster?
-
the ptbnl list should be included in the trade comments
-
agree with andy's comments about ptbnl later. I agree with the premise. However, it needs to be stated in the trade comments and/or the message board comments. Additionally, the ptbnl needs to be on the roster already and cannot be, i will pick up a guy later and i will send him your way.
-
Piscotty for nothing to carcass... Deal. I'm offering it up now
-
I am going to interrupt the snark here to address the ptbnl idea. I don't know that I have a problem with it in theory, but it should be spelled out in the comments of the trade. You are letting people veto a deal without having all of the information. And then even if that passes, you later have to deal with trading a player for nothing and avoid that being vetoed. We should probably discuss the PTBNL at the next Owners Meeting.
-
for the record, i would not have traded jdm for lopez (in case there was any doubt)
-
Do I need to go back and post the crappy offers I was getting for Ozuna? It will take some time, but I can
-
Hey, does anyone want my injured players for some top tier pitching? They aren't going to play again this year, so you can have them.
-
hey nick, trade me piscotty. I will trade you miguel cabrera. he's not on my team right now, but i will get him later and send him to you then
-
I don't mind if people veto. It was just a fun idea. I get a high level pitching prospect as well as a prospect TBD. Anyone I want, at anytime... I will buy the player for cost. Let me know what you guys think. I have offered ozuna to 75% of you and all refused to pay for him. I feel like Lopez is high level prospect. Which no team was even offering me that... Just an a bunch of cuts....With quotes saying Ozuna cant be trusted
-
No vetos need to happen, it also includes a player to be named later-a prospect that is not currently on my roster. Even if that wasn't the case, there could be arguments made for all kinds of lopsided trades. It's not like Lopez is some injured guy plus he is a keeper type prospect.
-
What is that? That has to be vetoed
-
maybe sco has chris correa on staff? another possibility
-
Every once in a while, someone presses the wrong button and hits accept when they meant to hit reject. That's another possibility.
-
there has to be more to it right, right?
-
Was there actual cash exchanged in a deal today? Like U.S. currency?
-
Abreu, Kluber and either of Melancon/Davis on trade block.
🐸Da Frogz🐸 on
July 20, 2016 9:37 PM
-
So is this one... http://www.fangraphs.com/fantasy/xander-bogaerts-the-next-big-thing/
🏰TheKingdom🏰 on
July 19, 2016 4:50 PM
-
This is a really good article.... http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/carlos-correa-looks-historically-great/
🏰TheKingdom🏰 on
July 19, 2016 4:48 PM
-
Looking at moving one of Carlos Correa or Xander Bogaerts for an OF, 3B, or SP package, or 1 for 1 swap if value is right.
🏰TheKingdom🏰 on
July 19, 2016 9:18 AM
-
builtfromScratch vs CitiMortgage's trade block has been updated!
🏰TheKingdom🏰 on
July 19, 2016 9:15 AM
-
Ian Desmond for sale
-
Cubanos!
-
I see Empire brought his checkbook out tonight.
🏰TheKingdom🏰 on
July 17, 2016 9:02 PM
-
I mean WTF
-
I don't know who you're talking about I don't have a Bundy on my team (anymore)
🏰TheKingdom🏰 on
July 17, 2016 2:34 PM
-
Welcome aboard mr bundy!
-
Ah, it feels good to be back to hating my players
-
Hey look! A trade. Shall we consider that a slumpbuster? It's been a week since our last one was agreed to.
-
whatever that is, i am pretty certain it was more trouble than it was worth
-
10: J Baez $9 – builtfromScratch 9: Schwarber $10 – builtfromScratch 8: Bogaerts $17 – builtfromScratch 7: Hosmer $20 – builtfromScratch 6: Springer $21 – builtfromScratch 5: Correa $24 – builtfromScratch 4: Zobrist $25 – builtfromScratch 3: J Jaso $1 – Carcass 2: K Bryant $31 – builtfromScratch 1: Goldschmidt $61 - builtfromScratch
🏰TheKingdom🏰 on
July 13, 2016 2:35 PM
-
and your TOP 10.......
🏰TheKingdom🏰 on
July 13, 2016 2:35 PM
-
20: W Ramos $1 – builtfromScratch 19: Profar $2 – builtfromScratch 18: J Turner $3 – builtfromScratch 17: I Happ $3 – builtfromScratch 16: Dahl $3 – builtfromScratch 15: Conforto $4 – builtfromScratch 14: Kepler $4 – builtfromScratch 13: B Moss $5 – builtfromScratch 12: LeMahieu $5 builtfromScratch 11: Valencia $5 – builtfromScratch
🏰TheKingdom🏰 on
July 13, 2016 2:35 PM
-
30: J Ross $5 – builtfromScratch 29: A Nola – builtfromScratch 28: H Strickland $6 – builtfromScratch 27: J Taillon $6 – builtfromScratch 26: K Gausman $8 – buitfromScratch 25: S Matz $9 – builtfromScratch 24: Noah $11 – builtfromScratch 23: Keuchel $17 – builtfromScratch 22: DeGrom $23 – builtfromScratch 21: Vogelbach $1 – builtfromScratch
🏰TheKingdom🏰 on
July 13, 2016 2:35 PM
-
40: C Reed $1 – builtfromScratch 39: E Diaz $1 – builtfromScratch 38: M Feliz $1 – builtfromScratch 37: B McCarthy $1 – builtfromScratch 36: A Conley $2 – builtfromScratch 35: N Jones $3 – builtfromScratch 34: M Bush $3 – builtfromScratch 33: K Herrera $3 – builtfromScratch 32: M Givens $4 – builtfromScratch 31: T Walker $5 – builtfromScratch
🏰TheKingdom🏰 on
July 13, 2016 2:34 PM
-
So, in honor of Fangraphs trade value series, I thought I'd post trade value rankings for our league! I came up with a top 40 based on cost, production, and confidence level of continued performance. I'll post them in increments of 10.
🏰TheKingdom🏰 on
July 13, 2016 2:34 PM
-
Raises hand
-
Does anyone want to trade?
-
Was there a 30 day return policy on kimbrel?
Previous 50 messages |
Next 50 messages